A shaking hand can happen for many reasons. For millions of people, it’s a sign of essential tremor, a common movement disorder that can sometimes be confused with Parkinson’s disease.
Essential tremor and Parkinson’s can look similar, but there are important differences in their symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment. Getting an accurate diagnosis can help you better understand your symptoms and find the right approach to managing them.
Here’s what you need to know about the key differences between essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease.
The nature of the tremor itself is one of the clearest ways to tell essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease apart.
A tremor is a specific type of shaking that affects a particular area (or areas) of the body. It is unintentional, meaning that the person experiencing the tremor is shaking without meaning to.
A key difference between the tremors seen in essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease is when they occur: at rest or with movement.
People with essential tremor shake when they’re using a body part, a pattern doctors call an “action tremor.” People with Parkinson’s disease are more likely to shake when a body part is resting, known as a “resting tremor.”
Picture someone relaxing on a porch. If they have essential tremor, you might not notice anything until they reach for their glass — that’s when the shaking starts. If they have Parkinson’s disease, you’re more likely to see the tremor while their hand rests in their lap or on the arm of the chair.
This is the typical pattern, although it doesn’t apply to everyone all the time. In essential tremor, the shaking doesn’t always stop completely once the movement is finished, and some people with Parkinson’s disease have a tremor that shows up during movement instead of at rest.
A few other clues can help tell the two tremors apart. Parkinson’s tremors tend to be slower and cover a wider range of motion than essential tremor. A hand tremor from Parkinson’s disease often starts at the wrist and ends with the fingers rubbing together, sometimes called a “pill-rolling tremor.”
Essential tremor tends to be faster and smaller, without that rolling motion. The tremor can also vary from person to person, which is why a neurologist will usually observe it during different activities and positions before making a diagnosis.
The two conditions also tend to show up at different ages. Essential tremor can appear at any age, but it’s most likely to start between ages 10 and 19 or between ages 50 and 59.
Parkinson’s disease is different — symptoms typically begin around age 60, and only a small share of people are diagnosed before age 40.
Family history offers another clue. More than half of people with essential tremor have a family member with the same condition or a related one, sometimes called familial tremor.
Parkinson’s disease can run in families too, but genetics play a smaller role overall. Researchers estimate that genetic factors cause about 10 percent to 15 percent of Parkinson’s cases, and most people diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease have no known family history of it.
Additional Symptoms In essential tremor, shaking is usually the main symptom a person notices. Parkinson’s disease involves tremor too, but a Parkinson’s diagnosis centers on another symptom called bradykinesia, or slowed movement, along with other signs. Not everyone with Parkinson’s disease has a tremor.
People with Parkinson’s disease often also develop muscle stiffness (rigidity), problems with balance and coordination, a stooped posture, and a shuffling walk. Furthermore, they frequently notice changes that have nothing to do with movement, like sleep problems or changes in mood, which essential tremor doesn’t typically cause.
Essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease also tend to spread through the body differently. Parkinson’s disease usually starts on one side of the body and, over time, often spreads to the other side, though symptoms typically progress unevenly between the two sides.
Essential tremor is different — it typically affects both sides of the body from early on, though one side may still be a little more affected than the other. How much and how fast either condition progresses varies quite a bit from person to person, and neither follows exactly the same path in every case.
Because essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease involve different processes in the brain, they respond to different treatments. Parkinson’s disease symptoms usually improve with carbidopa and levodopa, a combination medication that doesn’t help with essential tremor.
People with essential tremor may see improvement with medications like propranolol or primidone instead. Propranolol is a blood pressure medication, while primidone is a seizure‑control medicine.
Alcohol affects the two conditions differently, too. People with essential tremor often notice their tremor eases for a while after drinking alcohol in moderation. People with Parkinson’s disease usually don’t see much change in their tremor after drinking alcohol.
Doctors once viewed essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease to be two completely separate conditions. Newer research suggests that having essential tremor may raise a person’s risk of developing Parkinson’s disease later on, though the two conditions remain distinct.
Scientists have also found signs of Parkinson’s-related brain changes, called Lewy bodies, in some people with essential tremor. However, this isn’t a consistent finding, and researchers aren’t yet sure what it means for the connection between the two conditions.
The exact relationship between the two conditions isn’t fully understood and continues to be explored. Many people with essential tremor never develop Parkinson’s disease, and many people with Parkinson’s disease never had essential tremor to begin with. However, it’s possible to have both conditions at the same time.
Neurologists, doctors who specialize in the brain and nervous system, diagnose both essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease. Diagnosis for both conditions is still mainly clinical, based on a person’s symptoms, a physical exam, and their medical history, including any family history of tremor or related conditions.
There’s no single test that can confirm essential tremor or Parkinson’s disease on its own, but imaging can sometimes help when the diagnosis isn’t clear from a neurological exam alone.
One option is a brain scan called a DaTscan, which is approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to help doctors tell essential tremor apart from tremor caused by Parkinson’s disease.
A DaTscan measures dopamine activity in the brain, and people with Parkinson’s disease usually show reduced activity. Because a DaTscan involves radiation exposure and isn’t available everywhere, it’s generally reserved for cases where the exam alone doesn’t give a clear answer.
Get updates directly to your inbox.
With Parkinson’s, do you ever experience an ankle swelling, or a hand swelling on one side of the body?
Become a member to get even more
This is a member-feature!
Sign up for free to view article comments.
I do not have tremors, did my research and knew I had Parkinsons, PC and neurologist did not agree,took a while to convence them.My balence is so bad I have to use a rolator to walk.If I had meds… read more
We'd love to hear from you! Please share your name and email to post and read comments.
You'll also get the latest articles directly to your inbox.